Most Useful Super Power

Debate Club
Image

Moderators: Prof. Kendra Givens, Prof. Alexander Brighton, Amy Smith, Ravenclaw Staff

Most Useful Super Power

Postby Gail Allen » Tue Apr 30, 2019 11:06 pm

What super power would be the most useful super power to have? All super powers have their definite benefits, but which one would be the most all-round useful one to have? Imagine you are the president and you get to pick to have one super hero with one super power at your disposal. What super power would this person have?

Image
Image
User avatar
Gail Allen
On my way to breaking the Roost!
 
 
Posts: 1476
Joined: Mon Sep 12, 2016 11:55 am

Re: Most Useful Super Power

Postby Dexter York » Sat Jun 08, 2019 4:14 pm

I shall be revealing the ultimate answer to this debate, and possible closure post.

The best super power of all time is the ability to adjust probability.

This super power defeats every single other super power. It will give you ultimate success in everything you want. Jumping off a building? Adjust the probability of hurting yourself to a low digit (like 1.0×10^-9) and you survive. Same goes for anything else, it could be getting fat, winning the lottery, sleeping in every day and not getting fired, anything at all.

Image
Dexter York
My MC is a... ACK! It ran away!
 
Posts: 4
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2018 11:13 pm
Location: Slytherin

Re: Most Useful Super Power

Postby Finn Cullen » Sat Nov 16, 2019 9:28 pm

If the premise is not simply what is the best superpower (which would certainly be having an armpit that dispenses sun-block) but which superpower you would like at your disposal if you were President then I would argue as follows.

The role of President suggests some political post. As Orwell posits in 1984 the goal of any person or group in power is to remain in power. Therefore as President I would like to have a superhero at my disposal who had the power to make people believe what I told them. No matter how unlikely, no matter how contrary to other evidence, no matter how dissonant with previous messages, the people would believe. Policies could be advanced, resistance eliminated, social trends changed and shaped. Imagine Twitter but in a cape.
Hello everyone my name is Finn Cullen and I'm a Ravenclaw!
Finn Cullen
On my way to breaking the Roost!
 
 
Posts: 2784
Joined: Fri Aug 10, 2007 8:03 pm

Re: Most Useful Super Power

Postby Prof. Maxim Trevelyan » Tue Nov 30, 2021 8:58 pm

This is my usual answer with these topics, but I think the most useful superpower to have would be the ability to (re)fill anything possible, either physical or not in nature. It would basically give you anything you wanted, or give you the necessary quantity of tools to do what you wanted.

Are you thirsty? Refill your glass. Do you need money? Refill your bank account. Do you have that annoying neighbor that keeps letting their dog go potty on your lawn? Refill their bladder.

I also cannot really see the drawbacks to the power either. You cannot overdo it as it always fills up only to the brim, kind of, but you could be exploited by other people if you let your powers slip.
Image
User avatar
Prof. Maxim Trevelyan
My MC is a... Mackled Malaclaw
 
Posts: 381
Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2015 10:19 pm

Re: Most Useful Super Power

Postby Caius Magnusson » Tue Sep 06, 2022 2:27 pm

My response to this question is very similar to some of the previous answers, although I think it's more precise / specific than what has been provided so far.

Personally, I think the most useful super power is the ability to change the rules of reality.

This might seem vague at first, but it becomes clearer once we think about specific cases. For instance, if a person wants to always have money, they can add a rule that states "a bank account from which I withdraw money will always have at least $1,000,000 available, with no legal issues or resulting inflation arising from withdrawing, using or transferring that money". Essentially, you rewrite a wish of yours into the very core of the universe, making it part of reality.

This is very similar to the idea of modifying probabilities proposed by Dexter, but there are two issues with probability modification - you could theoretically be extremely unlucky and get the negative outcome if the probability is non-zero, and probability modification requires you to account for all scenarios related to a situation. Maybe you're not getting hurt if you are jumping off a building if you alter the probability of injury, but you could very much have a panic attack and get PTSD from the practice, depending on how you defined injury. If you closed that loophole by defining injury as being either physical or psychological, there might be still another form of harm you might be subject to that you have not foreseen.

On the other hand, if you alter reality to account for the room "no harm of any kind will arise from me falling from any height, with this rule accounting for both the falling process and the subsequent impact", then all possibilities are addressed. You can't suffer physical harm, psychological harm, financial harm (from breaking a third-party object that you need to replace) and so on and so forth.

Of course, there's the potential of someone twisting a rule in a very negative way, so it is a mighty dangerous power too. However, that does not remove its nature as the most useful one, provided it's used sensibly.
User avatar
Caius Magnusson
My MC is a... Horklump
 
Posts: 20
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2022 6:35 pm

Re: Most Useful Super Power

Postby Hiya Debnath » Wed Mar 13, 2024 11:42 am

I think that the most useful superpower is the ability to create unlimited happiness. There have been so many instances in history and so many events in fictional tales in which a person or being asked for a certain superpower or for some other boon because they weren't happy with their current circumstances, but upon the circumstances being changed, they were still not satisfied and then wanted something else, possibly even completely the reverse of what they had earlier wanted. For a few mere examples, King Midas asked for a touch of gold, that is, whatever he touched would turn into gold, signifying that he thought that wealth was the ultimate boon, only to discover that it wasn't really the ultimate boon. King Ashoka wanted to conquer the world, but converted to Buddhism when he noticed all the bloodshed and began to crave peace thereafter. I have known instances when people chose to remain a subordinate because they wanted peace and did not want to be involved with the responsibility of making decisions, but, then craved more power nevertheless. They wanted to change reality but were never happy nevertheless even after the reality was changed because they wanted something else. The truth about the human mind is that it can only be happy when it is chasing something or pursuing something. We do not realise it and think that want and need is the source of all sadness and dejection, but in reality, fulfilling a want or need is exactly what we live for. We would never stop wanting or needing anything. If we had everything, we would possibly want more, even eye that that is impossible, and even if we achieved the impossible, our happiness would be longer lasting but still just temporary nevertheless. We think that if we had that one thing, we would be happy. But we do not realise that if we had that one thing, we would be craving something else, because once we had that thing, we would find it boring now that that thing is ours and doesn't provide the thrill of the chase or of pursuing something. We are all thrill-seekers by nature even if we do not admit it. Even those who say that they only want a stable job nevertheless engage in various pursuits outside even the stablest possible job, just to get a thrill out of it. It is human nature to want and need more and more and keep looking for development, even when they seem to have everything, because our definition of everything keeps changing. If we had conquered the whole world, we'd be looking to space. In other words, joy and happiness is always momentary and fleeting to us. Fulfilling a need makes us happy temporarily only to become the starting point of another need. So, I would say that the best superpower is that of the ability to be happy unlimitedly, irrespective of the circumstances. That is the only thing that would actually keep a human being content and stop them from wanting more, and make them finally fulfilled and without any needs.
Image
"Happiness can be found, even in the darkest of times, if one only remembers to turn on the light." - Albus Dumbledore.
User avatar
Hiya Debnath
My MC is a... Chizpurfle
 
 
Posts: 107
Joined: Fri Nov 10, 2023 6:14 pm


Return to Bird to Differ

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests


cron